I went for their Ice Cream for Breakfast day and it was amazing. I have to go back. The ice cream was the best I've had in a long time.

I just tried this place for the first time last week, and I loved it! I got peanut butter ice cream in a waffle cone and it was delicious! I would definitely come here again.

Some of the best ice cream and kindest staff my wife and I have enjoyed. The ice cream is delicious, the people friendly , and the location excellent!!! If you get the chance, have a milkshake !!!

The ice cream here is really good and they have a lot of unique flavors (birch beer ice cream ??).

Yes, the chocolate pudding ice cream is great, but you know, there's a reason they ALWAYS have banana ... Because it is the most awesome ice cream EVER!!

The creamiest ice cream around. Try the Ginger ice cream , it takes very good. Also a really good flavor is the Burnt Sugar . Burnt Sugar also makes for a really good "smoosh-in" Read more

The best hot fudge !!! Taste like brownie mix almost! Highly suggest it as a topping to any flavor!

The coffee No-Moo (dairy-free ice cream ) is delicious!

The mud pie is the best ice cream of all time. Don't miss it.

Love the chocolate pudding with the vanilla on a cone with chocolate sprinkles .

Now accepting credit cards! Try the English toffee crunch.

Dutch Orange Chocolate and Triple Malt were two tasty less-common flavors today.

Delicious homemade ice cream

When ice cream is going to this good there needs to be a warning... amazing!

I suggest dipped waffle cone with blackbery and lemon

It's Herrell's and it has been outstanding since the doors opened.

Best hot fudge & fresh whipped cream hands down!

Best ice cream in NOHO hands down.

Great vegan options and secret vegan menu !

Chocolate Pudding . Just get that flavor and forget all others.

Most fantastic flavor: Chocolate Pudding . Your tummy will tremble.

Tried the mint cookies & cream . Had a distinct natural flavor, but the texture was nothing special.

Herrell's Chocolate Sprinkles - the best I ever had!

Different flavored every day. Happy Couple is our favorite.

Best ice cream around! Try the PB&J flavor, tastes just like the sandwich minus the bread !

You must try their world famous ice cream . Hand made and absolutely delicious!

The jalapeño ice cream is awesome!

Chocolate Pudding is to die for!!!

Mud pie , ice cream cookie sandwiches

they have vegan ice cream !!

You only get two tastes. One of them should be Burnt Sugar & Butter.

Good ice cream , small portions

Best hot fudge . You can buy a jar to bring home.

Chocolate non-parelle waffle cones are great

Avoid the sorbets , sherbets , etc... underwhelming. Stick to the regular ice creams , all of which are top-notch.

The ginger ice cream is delicous!

Try a malted shake , a Jack White favorite

Great ice cream !

Burnt sugar and butter ice cream . Oh. My.

Also if you have a favorite,don't expect it to be there the next time you go flavors change all the time

Peanut butter and cookie dough

Try anything with maple

The mudpie ice cream is phenomenal!

Whatever you order, get the home-made chocolate whipped cream on it.

Try the nondairy ice-cream; it's amazing!

Triple malted and mudpie FTW.

Cookie dough peanut butter swirl is soooo good

Michael says the pudding flavor is good, but bugZ says it is just OK

No wheelchair access