This is a nugget of pure gold. Had the Calamari starter, lightly grilled & stuffed with prawn mousse . The polenta eggplant lasagna is to die for!! And don't forget the chocolate mascarpone cheesecake

Best restaurant anywhere near Redwood . If you can, order everything, but otherwise get the Brick Bird and homemade ice cream . And Anna is the bees knees.

The Wild Mushroom Cobbler is a must try. I'm not much of a mushroom fan, but I devoured this appetizer .

Enjoyed the experience! Great veggie options . Tasty. Good service though they forgot some of our orders. Watch their tip policy...they calculate post-tax vs pre-tax.

Only place to go in Eureka. 2 doors down is a great place for a drink before. Or order pizza from there.

As DD show suggests mushroom cobbler is amazing. But to be fair , everything we had, pizzas , squid were also perfect. Cheers to the chef and the staff

Amazing place! service is very good! Food is excellent!!

Our favorite lunch spot in Eureka! We plan our travels around stopping here, but have yet to eat our way through the entire delicious menu.

Pizza is great! Mushroom cobbler . Bug wine list and lots by the glass.

Cute restaurant with great food. The mushroom cobbler , rock cod , and brick chicken are all winners.

Pork ribs w Polenta and mushroom cobbler are SO good

if you're driving along 101, this is absolutely worth a short detour. the pizzas are v unique and the tuna sandwich is stellar

had the roasted ziti and the pizza with the peach , get them both if you go there. so good

Get the roasted oysters . They are pretty good. The wild mushroom cobbler is good too.

Check out Brick and Fire as seen on Diners, Drive-ins and Dives Read more

Fully booked yet amazingly accommodating staff

Good pizza for an overnight stop in Eureka. The feel is very.... what would you say.... bohemian ....

Absolutely everything!

Tuna nicoise salad .

As good as anything you'll find in the Bay Area! Try the mushroom cobbler and polenta lasagna....holy yum!

Call for a reservation . They didn't open until 5:00p today and were booked full by 3:30p. Great service and the food was very good.

Everything

This place is excellent - best in town . I had a hard time choosing what to order because everything looked bomb!

Avoid the associated wine joint "Two Doors Down." They are either cellaring the wines incorrectly or keeping them open far too long. I had 3 sour reds, all of which shouldn't have been.

If you have a discerning palate stay away. Wild mushroom cobbler was bland and boring. Polenta lasagna was burnt, sauce pedestrian and overall just bland, it came with a sad salad as well .

Polenta lasagne is amazeballs.

Very unhealthy food