Try the softshell crab sandwich it's great. You'll never get bored looking at the jokes and retro , vintage, or quirky stuff on the walls. They even have the Montauk monster!

Love this place! Fresh tuna steak in the tuna melt hit the spot. the fried asparagus is perfection! Definitely the most authentic Montauk.

Get the mussels on a cold day. Be advised tho, take your number 2 home with you.

Get the mussels . And the tilefish if it's on the specials board. Dig this place!

The only decent bar / restaurant left in Montauk.

Good local bar with a better than expected food menu.

Ask for multiple modifications to the menu and then ask George to tell you a story.

No cellphones allowed, ya summer idiot. You better be reading this from the parking lot or further.

Fresh seafood chill intimate dining off the grid

Try the softshell crab sandwich . It's awesome.

Great atmosphere, casual dining

The Tuna Melt is delicious!

Get the mussels (best ever!) and a bowl of the chili ! Great filling meal!!!

The said fish sandwich is our of this world

The fries were incredible ????

Get the mussels .

Melted cheese is simple but amazing. Vegetarian is classic.

Best mussels hands down and fantastic vegetarian sandwich !

Delicious Margarita's - fresh lime juice . None of that sour mix stuff.

Check out The Dock as seen on Bite This with Nadia G Read more

The baked clams ????

Bowl of Oyster Soup , Tuna Melt , Cold Beer .

Amazing fresh tuna salad !!

tuna melt - there's nothing else that compares

Mussels & a tuna melt .

The tuna melt is literally to die for

Mussels and owner best in "The Hamptons "

The peanut butter pie is amazing.

The greatest bar of all time.

Don't be a retard. Get the tuna melt .

Best mussels in the Hamptons . (Lotsa garlic !)

the nachos are a meal all by themselves

Best tuna melt in the world!

tuna melt is heaven!